California wants to crack down on Clear at the airport

Clear is a service that enables travelers to bypass security lines at airports and other venues by undergoing a biometric scan and paying an annual fee of $189.

Clear's Service Description

California lawmakers have proposed a bill to halt Clear's expansion in the state, citing concerns about the service creating divisions between travelers based on their financial means.

Legislative Action in California

The bill has cleared an initial hurdle by passing the Senate Transportation Committee with an 8-4 vote. However, it still needs approval from the full California Senate, Assembly, and Governor Gavin Newsom to become law.

Legislative Process

Clear operates at various locations, including airports, sports venues, and concerts. Members undergo biometric verification at kiosks and are escorted to the front of TSA security lines by Clear employees.

Clear's Operations

Some travelers view Clear's service as unfair, as it allows those with memberships to bypass lines while others must wait. Critics argue that access to efficient security screening should not be determined by financial status.

Public Concerns

Senator Josh Newman, the bill's sponsor, emphasizes the importance of ensuring equity in airport security experiences, stating that taxpayers fund these services and should not face unequal treatment.

Legislator's Perspective

Rather than abolishing Clear entirely, the bill aims to mandate separate security lines for Clear members and non-members, addressing the issue of line skipping while still allowing Clear to operate.

Proposed Solution

The bill has garnered support from organizations like the Association of Flight Attendants and some labor unions representing TSA agents. However, Clear, major airlines like Delta, California airports, and business groups oppose the legislation.

Stakeholder Positions